Murder in the Heartland - Season 5 (2022)

January 20, 1992, Twinsburg, Ohio: Charlene Puffenbarger, age 26, was found beaten, strangled and suffocated. Her son, Dustin Redmond, age 3, was the only witness to her brutal murder. As investigators continue to follow every tip that comes in, an unexpected source leads them to the killer. One suspect they look at is Willard McCarley, but the case goes cold for decades. Charlene's mother, Phyllis, does all she can to keep the case alive. Finally, in 2017, thanks to advances in DNA matching, Willard McCarley is convicted of Charlene's murder. He is sentenced to life ...

Greenfield Township, Ohio, March 13, 2006: When an Ohio man and wife, James 'Jim' Divelbliss and Karen Divelbliss, are found dead in their ransacked home, detectives turn to the community for help in solving the mysterious crime. Investigators piece together the events of a horrific night to uncover the truth of what occurred to these beloved local business owners who ran a 'Mom and Pop' variety store named "D and D Sales." They sold items such as tools, electronics, toys, gift items and bicycles. Tony Littrell gave the hard-working detectives a tip which helped close...

A tip comes in from an unexpected Willard, Missouri resident that leads to the final resting ground of missing newlyweds Russell 'Rusty' Porter, age 34, and Rebecca 'Becky' Porter, age 46. The couple was described as being very much in love and had been married for about a year. The Porters disappeared in April 2011. Their skeletal remains were found in remote Taney County in late July 2011. The coroner said each died of gunshot wounds to the head. In the end, their deaths were a murder-for-hire. Rusty's uncle, Robert Campbell, was the mastermind. Campbell hired his ...

October 1, 2019, Laurel Montana: Lori Bray, age 57, a good-natured casino employee at the Cedar Ridge Casino, is found dead in the woods in the small town of Laurel, MT. Investigators determined that she had been strangled. Captured on surveillance video from the casino, Bray is seen opening the passenger door of her car, a 2003 Chrysler, for a man to get inside. Investigation determined that she was giving Diego Hernandez, age 22, a ride home after her shift at the casino. In the end, Hernandez was found guilty of deliberate homicide for the 2019 death of Lori Bray. ...

Cloquet, MN: Native American Trina Langenbrunner was stabbed to death in 2000. Detectives and her Fond du Lac Reservation community worked together until 2012 when Joseph Couture was arrested. He was convicted and sentenced to 40 years.

After James Skinner turns up dead in his own bedroom, the agricultural community of Brownstown, Ill., enters into a paranoid spiral, unsure who would want to kill this beloved local rodeo rider and cattle rancher.

Twenty-year-old Kenyon College junior Emily Murray, a popular religious studies major, went missing late one night on November 3, 2000 after quitting her waitressing job at the Pirates' Cove restaurant and bar. A month later on December 9, 2000, her body was found in rural Vinton County, inside a trailer owned by Gregory McKnight, age 25, who worked in the kitchen at the Pirates' Cove. Detectives also located the body of Gregory Julious, whose charred remains were found elsewhere on Gregory McKnight's property. In the end, Gregory McKnight was convicted of all of the ...

October 6, 2008, Howard City, Michigan: Detectives investigate a night of horror that ends with the abduction of beloved couple Robert and Norma Bean, who are 66-year-old grandparents and business owners of 'R. Bean and Sons Transportation'. They had been forced from their Howard City, MI bed to a rural gravel pit in northern Kent County, where they met a violent shooting end to their lives. Local tips provide detectives clues, revealing the shocking timeline of their final hours. In the end, the culprits who were arrested, convicted and sentenced to prison were Bobby...

Lake Crystal, Minnesota, August 31, 2010: Jennifer Gilman Nibbe, a nurse, calls 911 to report that an intruder killed her husband, James Mervin Nibbe, age 26. He was a local electrician, and he was six years younger than his wife. During the murder investigation, law enforcement authorities thought that Jennifer's story was not credible. The evidence at the scene did not match her account of the events. In the end, the culprit was Jennifer herself. She was arrested and convicted. In July 2012, Jennifer Nibbe was sentenced to twenty-five years in prison.

The grotesque murder of a beloved citizen, Betsy Ball, age 67, shatters the quiet rural farm community of Vinton, Ohio. Her body was found on March 1, 2012. She had been strangled and her body had been abused. In the end, the culprit was Lee A. Hawkins, who had been an employee of Betsy Ball, and had worked for the Ball family on their farm. Hawkins was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Hartford, Kentucky, August 2, 2016: Driving over Short Creek Bridge, Doug McKenna spots a large pickup-truck toolbox in Short Creek and alerts the police. Inside the toolbox is the body of 29-year-old military veteran Tromain Mackall, who is originally from Prince Frederick, Maryland, and had only been in Kentucky for a few months. Tromain had met a transgender woman on the Internet and had moved to Hartford to be with her. Law enforcement detectives determine that Tromain was last seen alive at the home of William and Melanie Howard. Using interrogations and cell ...