Matthew Gray Gubler: The Unauthorized Documentary - Season 1 (2006)

Matthew rationalizes his kleptomaniac behavior on set. A Christmas celebration takes place, and Matthew has a little too much to drink.

Matthew revisits the topic of how smooth he is with the women working behind the scenes of Criminal Minds. The self-proclaiming "lady's man" strikes up a conversation with Lily Kershaw, who played a guest role in the show and had several of her songs featured during episodes. Her father, Glenn, a prominent member of the production staff interrupts with a strongly-worded warning towards Matthew. Guest star James Van Der Beek is caught off-guard when approached by an "old friend" from "The Creek" that he somehow cannot remember. Matthew explains the discrepancy, ...

Matthew notices that co-star A.J. Cook is expecting a child, which he fears could be his, although she refutes his presumption with the fact that they have never been alone together. When conversing with the recently-hired Paget Brewster about A.J. being pregnant, he takes an unusual approach to take their professional relationship to the next level. Matthew later confronts guest star Jason Alexander over past controversy surrounding his previous work on Seinfeld.

In response to the controversial footage released by the "hateful and spiteful" Andy Swan, Matthew claims he is a victim of selective editing and camera trickery. Anton Yelchin, a promising actor who played Nathan Harris in Season Two of Criminal Minds, comes to his defense.