2 Girls, 1 Cup: The Show - Season 1 (2008)

Cup orders a toilet disguise so that he can live out his ultimate fantasy with Alyssa and Sarah. As he waits for the delivery, he helps train Sarah for an acting role in a local theater show. He builds the costume and orders laxatives. When Alyssa falls ill, signs direct her to Cup dressed as a toilet. She sees through the disguise but is convinced that Cup was merely auditioning for the play.

Gerome discovers Cup attempting to dive into the toilet and takes him for a ride a car. Gerome pulls a gun on Cup threatening to reveal Cup's secret to his roommates. After revealing that he is half-Cup himself, Gerome snaps. He returns to the apartment threatening the girls at gunpoint. Cup takes a bullet to defend the women. A police officer arrives and kills Jerome.

Cup visits a psychologist for post-traumatic stress disorder over his witnessing the death of Gerome. The psychologist recommends that he try to meet and socialize with other cups. A cup named Frenchy appears and flirts with Sarah. Frenchy tells Cup his plans for Alyssa and Sarah. Cup exposes Frenchy as a fraud. Frenchy pulls a knife and Alyssa steps on him.